Search blog.co.uk

Book Report

by thysbe @ 2007-07-31 - 04:34:18 pm

I haven’t had much time for blogging this week because I have been reviewing books. Yes chaps I am a book reviewer – well – I’ve reviewed one or two probably not very well and not very accurately because I did drop one of them in the bath and the pages stuck together but there you are. I can now say that I have joined the ranks [tatty fringes] of serious journalism. Of course it would help if I could write in terse, well-crafted, precise sentences instead of waffling on for ages and then flitting off on tangents as soon as the fancy takes me. I notice that if you were to read any of my wordy constructions aloud you would probably die of asphyxia long before you got to the end. I should write thrillers – all beginning “It was a dark and stormy night” and go on for six pages without pausing for breath. Of course there was a time when short sentences were anathema – [now there’s a new word for the day] and were frowned upon especially by those of the legal profession who were paid by the word. That’s why your lease is forty-five pages long and dotted with hithertos and theretofores like currants in a figgy pudding. Plus it makes the author appear more substantial and formidably erudite the more words s/he uses even though s/he probably has no more idea than I do about what the hell s/he’s driveling on about. And as an aside if you want to appear to be the final authority on some topic or other it also helps if you can sprinkle your text liberally with quotations from Virgil or the Bible – using the original Latin Vulgate of course – or perhaps include a few pithy Bon Motes in Arcadian French.

But I digress – where was I? Oh yes – reviewing books. I enjoyed a couple of them – in fact one or two were a really interesting read i.e. Gordon Ramsay’s recent autobiographical offering: “Roasting in Hell’s Kitchen” – which goes quite some way to explaining just why he loses his temper so often and uses swear words as punctuation and hates his dad and has a low sperm count [standing in front of hot stoves all day – be warned] but then I ran into a veritable Great Wall of China of a book, which as you know was built to keep out invaders – and obviously book reviewers as well. I could not get through it with a steam shovel – or possibly a conquering horde of Mongolian Marauders. So now I’m on the horns of a dilemma [there’s those dilemma horns again]. The work is self-published – what was once called a ‘Vanity Press’ production – and before you give us the old French shoulder shrug and sneer at this, I believe Honore Balzac [also known as Honorary Ballsack amongst the uncouth classes] availed himself of the Vanity Press of his day – although I could be making that up – my memory for Farcical French potboilers is somewhat hazy.

Anyway – what to do about a really bad book? Do I slam it to the ground and jump up and down on the authors literary day-dreams or do I try and be politically correct – sort of like being the Paula Abdul of the book reviewing world – and say something along the lines of “this book was written entirely to the author’s own personal standards of satisfaction and was no doubt enjoyed by not only him but all of his friends and relatives too – and by the way I liked his picture on the back”, or do I go off on a Gordon Ramsay and declaim that he writes about as well as my old aunt Sally who is chained to a wall down at the local looney bin and thinks she’s the Shah of Iran? If there are any ‘real’ reviewers out there perhaps they would be kind enough to share some insights with me. In the meantime I have found a suitable use for what I like to call the ‘Doorstopper’ book – it’s quite good for resting your coffee cup on while you read about Jamie Oliver roasting his wienies over a slow fire [he evidently likes to cook in the nude – I never realized that his TV show the “Naked Chef" meant precisely that].


 
 

Trackback address for this post:

authimage

Comments, Trackbacks: Hide subcomments

kevinwilsonkevinwilson pro
2007-07-31 @ 16:50

you have to be honest because you owe it to the people who read your reviews, rather than owing anything to the person wot wrote it!

now, if i paid you a fiver, would you write a nice review of my blog...?

thysbethysbe [Member]
2007-07-31 @ 16:55

OOH a fiver! And in real money too - not Canadian Confetti! Tempting - very tempting...

Yes honesty is the best policy although not if you're married/in a serious relationship and your wife/boyfriend/girlfriend/significant other asks you "Do I look fat in this?" Answer truthfully at your peril - you wouldn't have one tail-feather left mate

It's a complete mystery to me, what drives the publishing world to publish certain authors and ignore others.

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:03

Your comment reminds me of Michael Crichton [who wrote Jurassic Park etc., etc.,] - he said he once submitted a little known story of Hemingway's to his university Professor in a writing class just to see what would happen. Hemingway got a 'C' - lol

NotBobNotBob [Member]
http://www.freewebs.com/notbob562/
2007-07-31 @ 21:52

I've got a fair few "Doorstoppers" (I prefer to call them Table Straighteners) that I only bought because of dodgy reviews. That's the main reason I tend to avoid professional reviewers. Just keep the reviews honest. If you think it's just so much piffle say so.
Far too many reviews I've read in the press have described what seem to be totally different books to the ones they say they are doing.

And as for the hype around the latest Harry Potter, well, don't even get me started...

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:07

Would you believe I haven't even had time to read it yet? I must be the only person on the planet who doesn't know the ending - ha. [Don't tell me]

Yes I agree - more truth from reviewers is necessary - not to mention truth in advertising. Wouldn't it be refreshing to see a 'Simon Cowell' type critique once in a while ;o)

joebanglesjoebangles [Member]
2007-07-31 @ 22:38

Book reviewers, film reviewers, both O K, but, what use are T V reviewers, it was on last night, I've missed it, who cares, anyway, surely it's a personal thing, just because a reviewer likes a thing does not necessarily mean that I will.

Good luck with the job.

deleted user [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 04:24

Oh it is so good to see that somebody else thinks that tv reviewers are a waste of space. Does anybody read them? As to the book, if you didn't like it, then you must say why. If there are good parts to the book, then include them, be fair, but honest.

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:11

Well there are certain reviewers that differ so far from my own taste that when they give something a crap review I watch it - when they give it a good one - I don't - ha. Here in Canada we have TIVO - which means we can record all the crap on TV to watch later. Makes it much easier to watch Corry and Boston Legal at times I know I won't be interrupted [like 4am in the morning - lol]

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:19

Well it's true but there are certain people who have no opinions of their own you see so pay to read mine - lol. Which is fine by me mate ;o)

TheBozzerTheBozzer [Member]
2007-08-01 @ 00:00

Well, you should just be honest, otherwise, (to be honest...) there's not any value in a review. It's the same on magazines, wot I have worked on - if you pander to advertisers, for example (in your case book publishers or authors) then people quickly realise and don't buy your magazine anymore because there's no value in the opinion. Then the advertisers don't advertise and then, well, you don't have a magazine. So, honesty in all things. But we should all remember - in the case of books, art, films, etc, it's only a personal opinion...
Now, where can I send my book and the fiver?

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:26

Yes I agree that a review has no value at all unless it's honest - that's why Simon Cowell is so successful - because he's not afraid to say what he thinks [and of course it makes for good television and certainly lines his pockets quite well or so I hear].

TheBozzerTheBozzer [Member]
2007-08-01 @ 12:46

Ah, there you go - honesty makes you rich (well, in Cowell's case anyway) and I think we should all aspire to that.

catdancercatdancer [Member]
2007-08-01 @ 06:51

I admire you - can't be easy, wanting to tell the truth but at the same time not wanting to hurt someone's feelings. I have given workshops in my time & it's hard to steer a middle course. Dropping in the bath is good though!

thisbe [Visitor]

2007-08-01 @ 12:31

Yes I think dropping it in the bath must have been some sort of unconscious statement on my part - or it could just be that I'm an almighty clutz and should not be trying to juggle three books, a plate of nibbles, a glass of wine, my glasses and the shampoo all at the same time. I wonder what Freud would have to say? Well not much really since he's dead but there you are..

Cheers

Leave a comment :

Your email address will not be displayed on this site.
Your URL will be displayed.
Allowed XHTML tags: <!, p, ul, ol, li, dl, dt, dd, address, blockquote, ins, del, a, span, bdo, br, em, strong, dfn, code, samp, kdb, var, cite, abbr, acronym, q, sub, sup, tt, i, b, big, small, img>
URLs, email, AIM and ICQs will be converted automatically.
Options:
 
(Line breaks become <br />)
(Set cookies for name, email & url)
Validation code:
Please enter the above code here:
For protection from spambots (case-sensitive).

Recent Posts

  1. Post-Christmas Blues
    by thysbe on 2008-01-22
  2. Remembrance Day
    by thysbe on 2007-11-09
  3. A Long Walk in the Woods
    by thysbe on 2007-10-31
  4. Future Day-Dreams
    by thysbe on 2007-10-03
  5. Size Matters
    by thysbe on 2007-08-30
  6. Open to the Public
    by thysbe on 2007-08-15
  7. Pottermania
    by thysbe on 2007-07-19
  8. Private Lives
    by thysbe on 2007-07-11
  9. Sicko
    by thysbe on 2007-07-07
  10. Ghost Stories
    by thysbe on 2007-07-06